IN 2005 on a dusty road in Tuz, Iraq, an American solder was killed by a
roadside bomb. His fellow soldiers soon discovered that the assassin was no
hardened terrorist, but an unemployed father of six who had been paid $200 to
plant the explosive. Such situations are not uncommon in Iraq, where high
unemployment spawned many “economic insurgents”—often unideological Iraqis in
need of cash, who became easy recruits. It was, in part, in response to examples
like this that a trio of former military officers created the Marshall Fund, a
private-equity fund making only non-oil investments in smallish firms in Iraq.
“Without thriving businesses and the jobs they create, Iraq will never be
stable,” says Dan Rice, who founded the fund along with Wayne Culbreth and
Andrew Eberhart. Late last year it closed on its first investment, a
tomato-processing plant in the northern region of Harir.
It is profit, not patriotism, that most excites Mr Rice about Iraq. In this,
he is not alone. Several multinational companies, from GE to Daimler Benz, have
opened up shop in Iraq since 2007, when the country started to become safer as a
result of America’s military surge. Luring these companies to Iraq are its huge
reserves of oil, abundant water supplies, fertile land and strategic location.
Then there are Iraq’s 30.7m citizens—all potential customers in a new consumer
economy who “need and want everything from televisions to washing machines,”
says Robert Kelley, one of a group of investors that is building a $120m luxury
hotel in Baghdad.
That said, the insurgency in Iraq, though diminished, continues to flare. The
country’s experiment with private enterprise is untested. Under Saddam Hussein’s
dictatorship, the state controlled everything from interest rates to jobs at the
bloated state-owned enterprises (SOEs) that dominated the economy. America began
paving the way for a free market in Iraq as soon as Baghdad fell in 2003. The
temporary American government abolished tariffs, freed interest rates, cut taxes
and stitched together a patchwork of market-friendly bankruptcy and other rules.
It also, in effect, shut down Iraq’s SOEs by restricting their access to cash,
cutting employees’ pay by 60% and barring the government from doing business
with them.
But a private sector failed to take root. In 2006, with unemployment and
underemployment in Iraq well over 50%, according to government estimates, the
American administration changed course. It created the Task Force for Business
and Stability Operations in Iraq to jump-start the private sector, this time
from the bottom up. The hope was that helping to create self-sustaining
businesses and, with them, jobs, would give Iraqis—including economic
insurgents—a stake in the country’s stability. It started by ensuring that
American contracts went directly to Iraqi businesses. Since 2006, $2 billion of
American contracts have been signed with over 5,000 private Iraqi firms. Next on
the agenda was to undo some of the damage from earlier American policies. The
Task Force received $50m in both 2007 and 2008 to restore production in Iraq’s
60 SOEs, some of which were running at 10% of capacity or less.
The Task Force’s most difficult job, however, was to find companies and
investors to put capital and know-how into Iraq’s SOEs and private firms. It
began arranging visits to Iraq for potential investors from around the world. It
provided transport, security, food, offices and accommodation in Baghdad’s green
zone, even today the only part of Baghdad where visitors from the West are
reasonably safe. And it made introductions to government officials and potential
Iraqi business partners.
The scheme has already notched up a few successes. Take Iskandiriyah, a
manufacturing town. The Task Force arrived in late 2006 to restart the many
factories once run by two SOEs there. Today they are producing machine parts,
trailers and machinery for the oil industry. Case New Holland, a maker of
construction equipment owned by Italy’s Fiat, began assembling farm tractors in
2007. In total around 5,000 Iraqis are back at work in Iskandiriyah’s two SOEs.
The town is considered stable.
The Task Force also helps smaller investors put capital to work in Iraq.
Consider the Marshall Fund’s $6m investment in the Harir tomato-paste factory,
for example. Iraq imports $100m of tomato paste a year, even as its tomato
farmers let their excess harvest rot on the vine, because Iraq has no way to
turn tomatoes into cans of paste. The Marshall Fund’s investment in a
tomato-processing plant not only gives factory workers a job, but gives tomato
farmers a bigger market and shopkeepers a locally made product. “And because we
expect to make a solid return—it’s a win, win, win, win,” says Mr Rice.
Last year foreign companies invested $910m in private Iraqi joint-ventures.
Individuals and investors such as the Marshall Fund put in another $500m for
start-ups. Will they reap profits or become a cautionary tale? As with many
things in Iraq, it is too early to tell. Most investors still consider the
country to be far too risky. The drop in oil prices is already causing a
budgetary squeeze for the government, which has had to stop recruiting police
and military personnel and reduce weapons purchases. The withdrawal of American
troops could leave behind a dangerous vacuum. The Task Force’s aim is for it be
filled by the private sector, not insurgents.
It's the economy, stupid - Source